FX Home
All Accounts
Mailing Lists

Your Account
Your Profile


Contact Us

Claim MEBord - Middle East borders change

Category: News:World News JUDGED at 0
Owner:861, David Cary
Judge:2568, JPO
due date:2005/12/15

The Claim

Between 2003-06-01 and 2005-10-15, either:

  • (a) At least one of the countries currently in the Middle East (as of the day this claim becomes active) will split into (at least) 2 countries, or
  • (b) at least one of the countries currently in the Middle East will merge with some other nation (perhaps one of the other Middle East countries).

For the purposes of this claim, a "country" is an area labeled as a country on the majority of reasonably unbiased maps.

For the purposes of this claim, the "Middle East" is the area covered by

  • Bahrain
  • Egypt
  • Iraq
  • Iran
  • Israel
  • Jordan
  • Kuwait
  • Lebanon
  • Oman
  • Qatar
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Syrian Arab Republic
  • United Arab Emirates
  • West Bank
  • Yemen

The judge is responsible for finding up-to-date and "reasonably unbiased" sources, and for posting their URIs in the judge's statement.

Look at what the cartographers "say" in their maps. Ignore what non-cartographers say or do.

---- related information, not officially part of this claim ----


The area labeled "Palestine (U.K.)" in 1945 maps has split into Israel and West Bank in 2003 maps. So "West Bank" counts as a country in 2003 for the purposes of this claim. If the West Bank becomes a completely independent nation labeled "Palestine", that is not enough for this claim to become true.

There are many slightly different definitions of "Middle East". Forgive me for introducing yet another one. This definition of the "Middle East" is similar to, but not exactly the same as "Western Asia" at http://www.un.org/Depts/Cartographic/english/ or "Southwest Asia" at http://geography.about.com/library/maps/blrmideast.htm .

Charter of the United Nations : Charter of the United Nations (1945) Article 2 paragraph 4. "All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations."

Why 2005-10-15 ? Chris Hibbert persuaded me it needs to be at least 2 years in the future, and I picked a random day of that year. I prefer claims spread throughout the year, rather than have them all expire on Jan 01.

I hope this will be extremely easy to judge.

Judge's Statement

This claim will be judged based on news reports available at The New York Times and the BBC, supplemented by map information available online from sources such as Mapquest and the United Nations.

Specific Country Notes:

  • Iraq - This claim will not be satisfied by a change of sovereignty in Iraq, or arrival or departure of US forces there. It will only be satisfied if Iraq itself splits into two or more separate countries, or merges with one or more countries.
  • West Bank - The claim description specifically cites the West Bank, so I will include it on the list of countries covered by this claim. However, not all maps currently show the West Bank as a separate entity, so the existence of a map showing the West Bank as part of Israel will not satisfy this claim.
  • Gaza Strip - As with the West Bank, current maps vary as to the status of the Gaza Strip. The Gaza Strip will only satisfy this claim if it itself splits, or merges with another state (other than the West Bank).

The Market

Price Plot for life of MEBord
Your UID:
Your password: